Sign In
Forgot Password?
Sign In | | Create Account

Embedded systems in cars - challenges and solutions

Complexity never, in itself, impresses me. I am impressed people’s ability to understand complex ideas and create complex machines, but a truly elegant and simple solution is always what gives me most pleasure. This might beg the question as to why I work in software – a business well known for creating incredibly complex things. I often ask myself the same question.

Systems where there are safety issues are a particular concern and a context, which is of interest to us all, is automotive systems …

When I first got a car [in 1975] there were really no electronic systems in vehicles at all. A few high end models had “electronic ignition”, but that was very primitive analog electronics that barely counts. That has all changed. Modern cars – even basic models – have dozens of microprocessors and microcontrollers, which span the complete spectrum of power/complexity from tiny 4-bit controllers to monster 32-bit [maybe 64-bit] supercomputers on a chip. Every system is electronic and a variety of design approaches are applicable. As I discussed in a previous post the degree of safety criticality in automotive systems varies and this has a significant effect on how they are implemented.

I am not a specialist in the automotive business, but I observe a particular characteristic which seems specific to car makers: they are very keen on standards. I believe that this comes about because, apart from being good business practice to take standards-based approaches to design when possible, the auto industry has a complex supply chain, so compliance with standards is easier to manage than individual, very detailed specifications. Some of the standards that apply to electronic systems in cars [not an exhaustive list]:

  • CAN Bus – a means to reliably connect numerous systems together whilst minimizing the amount of wiring.
  • MISRA C [and C++] – a detailed set of guidelines in the use of this language in a safety critical system, like a car.
  • OSEK/VDX – a standard for real time operating systems used in such systems in cars.
  • Genivi – a standard for Linux based systems used for in-car infotainment systems.

Although MISRA C has always interested me, I am particularly focused on the two operating system standards.

OSEK/VDX is a standard for RTOSes destined for use in automotive control systems. It was designed from the ground up for this purpose and incorporates the key characteristics needed for a safety critical system. The key feature is a lack of dynamic objects; everything is created statically at build time. The intrinsic simplicity of this implementation makes total sense to me, as it does not constrain the software designer significantly and eliminates a significant potential source of system failure. It is unsurprising that other industries are taking an interest in the standard. OSEK/VDX RTOSes are available from a number of vendors; it is also encompassed by AUTOSAR, which is a broader standard.

Most of the driver-facing systems in a car are not hard real time and do not have harsh safety requirements. So Linux is a good choice, as it opens up the availability of a wide range of off-the-shelf software components. Genivi is a standard for the implementation of Linux in this context. Mentor Embedded not only provides the Automotive Technology Platform, but is very active in maintaining and advancing this important standard. A recent announcement details support for Genivi 5.0. This on-demand Web seminar is a useful introduction to Genivi deployment.

The complexity of automotive systems means that deployment of a hypervisor, such as Mentor Embedded Hypervisor, becomes very attractive. This ensure isolation between sub-systems, thus increasing security and reliability.

OSEK, MISRA C, OSEK/VDX, Embedded Hypervisor, Linux, mentor embedded hypervisor, GENIVI, hypervisor

More Blog Posts

About Colin Walls Follow on Twitter

Colin WallsI have over thirty years experience in the electronics industry, largely dedicated to embedded software. A frequent presenter at conferences and seminars and author of numerous technical articles and two books on embedded software, I am a member of the marketing team of the Mentor Graphics Embedded Systems Division, and am based in the UK. Away from work, I have a wide range of interests including photography and trying to point my two daughters in the right direction in life. Learn more about Colin, including his go-to karaoke song and the best parts of being British: Visit The Colin Walls Blog

More Posts by Colin Walls


No one has commented yet on this post. Be the first to comment below.

Add Your Comment

Please complete the following information to comment or sign in.

(Your email will not be published)


Online Chat